You are here

UPDATE: Gifted and Talented

CastleJJ's picture

Some of you may recall, in December, BM emailed DH with test results indicating SS10 was "gifted". There was no actual message in the body of the email, just three images of a results report and a flyer about "giftedness." DH looked at the report. To be considered "gifted," SS had to score 128 or higher on this school administered test... he scored 132. SS10 was "gifted" by a whopping 4 points.

Our BM believes she is gifted herself. She maintained a 4.5 GPA in high school and claims to have an IQ of 160, same as Bill Gates. While she is academically very smart, which DH has attested to, she lacks in social skills and common sense. For the past 5 years, BM has made it her life's mission to get SS labeled as "gifted" because if he is not, it reflects poorly on BM since she holds academics and cognitive ability as the standard for success... typical narcissistic thinking. When SS was 6, BM had him tested for "giftedness;" SS did not qualify and was deemed average, which is when BM sought out the ADHD diagnosis that SS doesn't actually have. 

Today, BM sends DH another email. Again, no message in the body of the email, just an attachment with a letter from the school. Clearly, we didn't get the full story originally on this testing. We thought based on the original results BM sent, SS was labeled as "gifted" and that was that. Now we find out, there were two parts to this testing; the first was a standardized test that measured cognitive abilities. If passed (which SS did by 4 points), the school sent home a permission slip to obtain parental consent for further testing to measure creative abilities to determine if the child is actually gifted. If both the cognitive and creative areas were passed, then the child was labeled as "gifted." Well, the letter BM sent today indicated that SS did not pass the creative abilities test and is therefore not considered "gifted," but rather just "above average." DH and I have been saying this all along; SS is very smart and yes, sometimes above average, don't get me wrong, but he isn't special in his abilities. SS has told us himself that he still finds his grade level challenging at times. I'm sure BM is pissed about this. Makes me wonder if this test result has any connection to the whole toe walking issue and "sensory seeking behavior" related to SS' so-called ADHD that BM keeps emailing about since last time SS was denied a "gifted" label, BM had him diagnosed with ADHD. 

Comments

NotYourAverageStepMama's picture

cannot simply be happy with their child being happy and healthy, but instead there has to be something wrong with their child and/or they are above everyone else. It is totally okay to have a happy, healthy, normal child and I know there are tons of parents out there who wish they were so lucky that their child was just that. 

Probably an attention thing, but just so frustrating, there doesn't need to be something wrong or amazing every week about their child so they can be relevant and have somethign to message about. No news is sometimes GOOD news

CastleJJ's picture

I was raised that if you tried your best and applied yourself, then it was good enough. I didn't have to have straight As or be in all accelerated classes to be a good student. I didn't have to be the top athlete. I still did well in school, decent in sports, and have done well for myself professionally, but my parents always taught me that there was more to life than school and sports. 

It makes me sad that SS' life revolves around school and sports, especially at such a young age. He has told us that he wishes he had more time to be a normal kid. He doesn't ever have time to just play because BM is pushing academics and sports 24/7. SS is expected to be constantly reading, studying, practicing sports, etc. Even when spending time with his friends, he is still expected to practice drills and play backyard sports with them in his "free time" It doesn't surprise me that he lacks creative abilities because he has always been so regimented and struggles to think outside the box. 

NotYourAverageStepMama's picture

you are saying about trying your best and applying yourself, but having too high expectations can be stressful on children. Especially when it sounds like SS isn't the one pushing to be involved in so many sports. He is also only 12, not even in high school yet, so that does sound very intense! I agree, it sounds like he hasn't had the chance to be creative. Structure is definitely important and good, but sounds like every second of every day is planned out for him already. 

NotYourAverageStepMama's picture

Was 12. At ten not in middle school even makes it even worse! Activities and schedules are good, but kids also need time to be kids too. He has his whole life ahead to be scheduled. One sport and one club/activity should be sufficient enough. If he's doing well in school, let him go play!

CastleJJ's picture

Exactly. SS is in sports yearround, sometimes with only single day breaks between sports seasons. He has football in the summer and fall, basketball in fall/winter, and soccer in spring/summer. At our house, he doesn't have these commitments, so he gets to play. He loves playing with Hot Wheels, building forts, drawing, and doing crafts. He always says he never gets to do those things at BM's... it's always school and sports. I can't imagine being that age and having that lifestyle and the sad thing is, SS has been accustomed to that lifestyle since he was in Kindergarten. 

Winterglow's picture

Your BM may have "smarts" but anyone who has half a brain knows that you need to continue building on that for the rest of your life. Intelligence isn't a constant and shouldn't be an impediment to continuing to learn. Your brain isn't suddenly full. Anyway, if she'd bothered to educate herself on child development (and how many mothers do not have at least one book on the subject, eh? lol) she would know that play is an essential part of a child's life, that play actually teaches them about getting on with others,  using their imagination, problem-solving, etc. 

"when kids don’t have the opportunity to play outside in nature, they are at higher risk for attention problems and behavior problems,” (...) “Without proper play, kids do not have the chance to stretch their imagination and build the skills they need to succeed in the workplace and in their life. A lack of play can also stunt an individual’s social and emotional development.”

https://www.healthline.com/health/the-importance-of-play#when-kids-dont-...

She is doing him way more harm that good ...

shamds's picture

Kids are better than everyone else. There is no humility and when the bragging backfires on them, they can't take it and make some sob story poor innocent me i'm sick or disabled and have an imaginary illness for sympathy 

its 100% out of the narc mums playbook. Its pathetic.

you can claim your kid is a straight a honours student or graduated with a degree with honours but if they're are piece of shit human, I don't care about those straight a grades, they mean nothing to me

strugglingSM's picture

I used to work for an affluent school district and the push to get into the "gifted" program was huge. Affluent districts often have a higher percentage of 504 plans than non-affluent districts, to allow for accomodations for gifted (and non-gifted) students, especially for extra time on standardized tests like the SATs. They are also more likely to have a higher proportion of students labeled as "twice exceptional", gifted, but also qualifying for special education. Often this is because they "struggle" to keep up with gifted coursework in one area...god forbid anyone admit that they were just "average" or even "above average" in that subject area.