Refusing to do class tests.
Hypothetical situation:
Let's say you go to a parent-teacher interview and the teacher shows you a series of in-class test results marked with 0%. Apparently your child opted to just not do the test. When asked why, the kid just shrugs his shoulders. Teacher tells parents that she gave the kid detention and instructed him to re-do the test (basically giving him a second chance). Kid comes to detention and just sits there still refusing to do the test. Your kid doesn't say anything. He just sits there and winds the clock down. Again, when asked why he is refusing to do the test, the kid just shrugs his shoulders.
Now imagine you are the parent of this kid and you are hearing this for the first time. What would you do?
- Drac0's blog
- Log in or register to post comments
Comments
well when YOUR child does
well when YOUR child does this, your going to have to do what you feel you need to do to get him/her moving
but if this is your step son, I personally would ask the school for some OBJECTIVE advice for HIS mother.
you need to do nothing with this, if you do with the tactics and attitude you usually have towards your SS it will escalate and make it worse. I get where your attitude comes from I just dont get how you keep it going and going and going. It is like the defination of insanity and it isnt working. It wasnt working 3 months ago the last time I left a note.
step away from the situation Draco.
If it was my own kid, I would be working hand in hand with the school and the counselors put in place to help the child.
>If it was my own kid, I
>If it was my own kid, I would be working hand in hand with the school and the counselors put in place to help the child.<
What if you are already doing that? Is there something more you would do?
Point again!
Point again!
DW IS very open minded. Right
DW IS very open minded. Right now, she is absolutely furious and doesn't want to make any decision out of anger.
If this were MY kid, he'd be
If this were MY kid, he'd be grounded for the rest of the school year. No electronics, no special events, nothing.
If this were my STEPkid - as is the case here - I'd let their parent handle it. And I would try not to get annoyed when, inevitably, their PARENT doesn't do what I would do.
^^^^Agree with both of
^^^^Agree with both of these...
In your case... the question you posed yesterday about karate... I would tell the kid to say goodbye to that for sure!
>Draco? If this isn't the
>Draco? If this isn't the result of your wife coddling her widdle baby boy, then she better buck up and straighten him out NOW. It will just get worse.<
Last night was a bit of a wake-up call for DW. She was shocked. I mean she was honest-to-God SHOCKED that her son, who has always been polite and easy-going, would outright refuse to do assigned classwork (and a test to boot!). This certainly isn't like him. Needless to say she didn't sleep well last night. Sure, she is pissed off but she is certainly very worried too. All the teachers have warned us that a lot of the subjects being taught was a review from last year (which would explain why SS excelled in some of the classes) but from here on out, it gets harder. So you're right there. If things don't change, it will get worse.
I just threatened BD10 with
I just threatened BD10 with this last night! She got a failing grade on an assigment last week. I told her she'd better get with the teacher the next day and arrange a redo. Oops, didn't happen. So Tuesday rolls around, I tell her again she'd better get this fixed. Didn't happen. She gets a day of no TV. Wednesday rolls around, oops again. I take her iphone for two days. I tell her if it is not fixed TODAY, I will be showing up in her classroom in person and asking the teacher in front of the entire school how to deal with a kid with a failing grade who CHOOSES (forgetting three days in a row IS a choice) not to deal with the situation on her own. Hoping BD10 has fixed it herself when I see her tonight, otherwise I'll be showing up at school (she thinks I am bluffing).
Hmmm...I really do not know
Hmmm...I really do not know what I would do.
My kids would have NEVER just out and out disrespected the school, teachers, or parent by just boldly refusing to take a test.
But I am pretty sure my kids and your SS were raised WAY different.
Love4lemons, if your child
Love4lemons, if your child willfully does these things, I would definetly be doing what you are doing. When SS was 8 he would do similar things but it was never, ever, EVER willful. He wouldn't lie, cheat, hide the truth just to get out of trouble. His ADHD just made it difficult to concentrate on the tasks that were assigned to him and it also made him forgetful. When he says "I forgot" it really meant I FORGOT.
But now, we are seeing a completly other side to SS that we have never seen before. Not only is he not doing his work but he is doing everything he can to avoid doing it and stay under the radar.
"Duh?" was exactly my
"Duh?" was exactly my reaction! SS may have his faults but SS ALWAYS does what he was told. Flat out and willfully refusing to do what a teacher tells him to do is a new leaf that SS has turned over.
Of Sh*T!!! Love4Lemons, I
Of Sh*T!!! Love4Lemons, I appologize. I was actually trying to delete one of my own posts! I was wondering why I deleted my post and it was STILL there!
It's not like I don't like your application to my life. It's just that it doesn't apply. However, that is not to say that DW is in fact looking for opinions on what to do. I've weighed in already.
^^^^Perfect!
^^^^Perfect!
Ladyface, you're starting to
:jawdrop:
Ladyface, you're starting to scare me. Were you hidden in the back seat of our car eavesdropping on our conversation on the way home!?
LOL! My Dad threatened me
LOL! My Dad threatened me with this. I had no doubt in my mind he would do it too. It straightened me out real quick!
I'm really amazed that this
I'm really amazed that this would be the first your DW would be hearing about this. At my school a parent would have been notified the very day of first refusal. Detention would have had to also be signed off on and acknowledged by parent. A second refusal to take test during detention? The kid would have been suspended here. Insubordination is not tolerated in the classrooms here.
Kid stuff like not shutting up, passing notes, blah blah in the main classes are considered 'misconduct' and they use the detention route. But outright refusal to participate in classroom work during class time rises above normal bratty kid misconduct and enters more serious nature category. So what is the school recommending in this 'hypothetical' scenario situation of yours?
>I'm really amazed that this
>I'm really amazed that this would be the first your DW would be hearing about this. <
You want to know what REALLY happened?
SS has a record chart that the teacher keeps notes in and of the weekly test results. Once a week she asks the students to bring the charts home and get them signed. SS "lost" the sheet. So the teacher gave him her copy and told him to go to the library to photocopy it. SS took the sheet....and never returned it. When the teacher asked where the sheet was, SS simply replied with a shrug.
Teacher told him that he wasn't being very smart. One way or another, SS's parents will be notified of this.
Guess what? We've just been notified!
To answer your second question, we spoke to 4 teachers last night and ALL of them have recommended that SS spend his lunch breaks in the class to catch up on the multitude of assignments he is not doing.
ETA: Deleted your duplicate post.
And if he has to miss lunch
And if he has to miss lunch to make up assignments wtf is he doing on a field trip enjoying himself???
I answered this above. Had we
I answered this above. Had we known this before SS left, his field trip would have definetly been cancelled. SS did write a letter of appology to the councilor and ultimately, it was the councilor who had final say on whether SS can go or not. We didn't know ALL the little gory details though.
Yes there is, but not all
Yes there is, but not all teacher's use it. What is even more aggravating is that the real important big projects (the one's that count for a lot of marks) are not always on there either. This is an issue that a lot of parents have. Fortunately, the teacher we spoke to last night (the one who SS refused to do the test) says that she updates the portail daily. So we will definetly be checking it!
The way she explained this
The way she explained this was that she told SS that she would give SS a chance to come clean with us about his refusing to do tests. She warned him that one way or another, his parents would find out BUT she would give a chance for a re-do. He didn't take it so the teacher - being just as surprised as we are with this - reported it to the councilor and the councilor called us.
They call you AFTER the kid
They call you AFTER the kid goes on over night field trip ??
That makes no sense what so ever !!!
No, no! They called before
No, no! They called before the field trip.
Timeline was like this:
SS fools around in class
Teacher's warn him and advise the councilor.
Councilor asks SS to meet with her to discuss his behavior.
SS blows off meeting
A week before the field trip the councilor calls us.
DW blasted SS and got him to write a letter of appology to the councilor and to the teachers.
SS did so and he actually wrote a pretty darn good letter. Seriously, when I first read it, I thought DW was ghost writing for him.
SS hands in the letter to the councilor who was also impressed and gave her permission for SS to go on the trip.
We go to parent-teacher interviews and we hear what's going down in the trenches.
I am just flabbergasted that
I am just flabbergasted that the school didn't notify you guys earlier. I would be pissed at the school n would have told them that. All they did with not notifying you has glorify his behavior for him. He thinks he got away with it. I would have told the school off ~ saying notifying me would have made me refuse the trip for him. A beginning to his punishment.
His Christmas gift should be a donation to a local charity in his name.
My nephew was a bad ass like this ~ he stole my fathers mustang n went joy riding in it. Took the car airborne n severed the brakes. Never told my father ~ my father knew it was him ~ cause he asked my Dad if he could wash the car. Come Xmas time my father have him a card n in it said
Merry Christmas !
Gift would be 100.00
- minus 50 for breaks
- minus 20 for sunglasses
Leaves you with 30 bucks ~ enjoy !
If this were my kid?? Of
If this were my kid?? Of course I'd be pissed. I dunno isn't an answer.
Something is going on with this child. It may be raging hormones, it may be ADHD, it may be meds (if he's being treated for ADHD), or it's a combination of things.
First and foremost, if this were my kid, I would take him away from home and school and have a little sit down with him. Not screaming or yelling but getting to the bottom of the real problem here.
If my child continued to clam up, then I would start with the removal of all privileges.
DH's kid purposely failed the 7th grade to prove a point, which was she didn't want to live with DH and I any longer. The grades slid, the attitude increased, then she started skipping school and finally ran away.
I suspect your SS is miserable and on the same track.
Draco, It really, really,
Draco,
It really, really, really is time to start considering medication for his ADHD. Karate is just not cutting it.
My D15's school has a parent portal where you can check all their grades online. She had a zero for a homework assignment. I emailed the teacher, who said she gave the class time to do the assignment in class. When I asked D15 what happened, she could not remember why she didn't do the assignment. This is a kid that always does her homework, I never have to get on her to do her homework. She will do skip doing anything else, hanging out with friends, watching TV, to do her homework. So I know it wasn't that she didn't want to do it.
This has happened a couple of times before, where for some odd reason she didn't do an assignment. She spaces out, doesn't focus and makes careless mistakes.
This past week we met with her psychiatrist who has diagnosed her as ADHD primary inattentive and prescribed her strattera.
If your SS needed glasses, I'm sure you would get them. Even though SOME of the times he does what he's supposed to, he's not consistent and that's the problem. The medication will help him be consistent with performing up to his potential.
I'd also be seriously
I'd also be seriously questioning the teacher why I wasn't informed of this situation until now. My kid is sent to detention......no note home? Being blatently defiant.....no note home? Flat out refusing to do classwork.... No call home? Esp with an over night field trip coming.....and this is the first I am heading of any problem??????
How many times was SS given
How many times was SS given detention? If he was given detention, that had to mean he got home later from school. Didn't you guys notice when he came home from school late?
Detentions are at lunch time.
Detentions are at lunch time. School doesn't have detentions after school anymore.
exaxtly draco and im sure you
exaxtly draco and im sure you may delete this comment but oh well. personally i think this child has zero self esteem and I feel this is at your hand. i read alot od your stuff and dont comment bur i really do think you take some normal teenage stuff and blow it up into something huge. and for why? because he isnt yours and your extremely hard on him. the boy has two parents and they need to handle it. and if it goes badly so be it. your constant insertion of your hard on for this kid is understandable, but your part of this problem let the solution be theirs. even in your not back to people you said we have not spoke to him. it should be his mom and dad speaking to him not we, you have zero skin in the game
This is going to come out bad
This is going to come out bad but we spent a good 30 minutes with the art teacher....
The things SS has to do in that class my DOG CAN DO! I kid you not! SS has a journal that he has to "fill in" with ANYTHING he wants! ANYTHING AT ALL!!! He can write trash, spill coke on, throw up on it and it would be considered ART!!!
I've said this before, so I
I've said this before, so I am going to have to save this so I can cut' and paste it whenever someone says this.
Yes. SS is NOT my kid. SS is the son of the woman I am MARRIED TO.
Our marriage and our commitment to SS's educational needs is what swayed the judges' final decision in making our home primary in our split custody with Donkeykong. Donkeykong is just itching - BURNING in fact - to file a motion for reversing custody based on the grounds that DW and I are not fulfilling SS's educational needs. It's a long shot, but that won't stop Donkeykong from trying should SS fail school.
Should that happen, you may as bring on the zombie apocalypse, because my life would be over. Finshed! With SS gone, DW will be utterly and completely devastated. I love my DW, but I cannot be with someone who is unhappy and misereable all the time. What is the point in me being a husband if I cannot make my wife happy? Maybe we can overcome this blow, but I would rather avoid the risk rather than be faced with such a difficult and heartbraking decision.
So I very much DO have a stake (skin) in this.
whatwasithinkin I TOTALLY
whatwasithinkin I TOTALLY agree. I think he is kind of afraid of you. Not physically of course...but I think he is going out of his way to hide things from YOU. You need to back off. If my DH treated my BS14 the same way you treat/talk about SS, I'd tell him to go fly a kite. Let DW deal with HER child. Let it go.
*blocks ears* Flintsones,
*blocks ears*
Flintsones, meet the Flintstones, they're a modern stone age family....
In all honesty? Kid would be
In all honesty?
Kid would be coming home to a military stripped room and grounded to that room. I'd ask the school to place them in lunch detention. If they disrupted class the teacher would be asked to send them to the detention/ instrument room (Some schools have them. They are sound proofed rooms that have nothing but a chair in them. Occasionally a piano.) to do their work. They can sit and shrug at the wall.
yes but 3little, this isnt
yes but 3little, this isnt you kid. but it isnt draco's kid either
No, that was me and what my
No, that was me and what my teachers did to me. My mom wouldn't help them out but they realized how badly I was struggling and that it was 90% ADHD that my mother refused to put me in therapy or on meds for... So I spent the a good month of 12th grade on social isolation at school. I thank God every day for those teachers. I had straight A's that term (and every term after that). If someone had done that 5 years earlier when I started flunking out, I probably wouldn't have ended up in Alt Ed.
LOL! Titty brains!! Love
LOL! Titty brains!! Love it! That could be the problem as well.
She must have read this book:
She must have read this book:
http://www.amazon.com/The-Defiant-Child-Oppositional-Disorder/dp/0878339639
Th book is great for finding new ways to deal with kids with ODD.
it was recommended to me on this forum. Whoever mentioned it to me several months ago (unfortunately, i forgot who it was) i am forever grateful! Thank you, thank you, thank you!
I do not know what issues the child in question has but i would not jump over about a dozen steps and move to take his bedroom door off its hinges. The kid is asserting his control over his life - by refusing to participate. Why not take a step back and try to piece together the big picture? What else is going on with him? Or with that teacher? Was there a bigger conflict with this teacher? What is happening in school? Was this an isolated incident or a recurring theme? How are his grades? Does he do his home work? is it only the classwork that suffers? In every class? Or in this teacher's class exclusively?
May be a school psychologist could help you find out.
Sure thing! You will love it
Sure thing! You will love it if you have an oppositional teen in your life.
Marie-Jeanne, i think one of the problems here is that these defiant kids think that sooner or later their parents will "run out of moves", according to Douglas Riley, my new hero, and author of the book i linked to. And if you start at the top ( taking his privacy, i.e. the door to this room, away) you *will* run out of moves when things - potentially - escalate. So far, the kid sat in class and ignored the assignment. I would argue this is not the end of the world. He did not call his teacher names, he not storm out of the classroom, did not go smoke pot in the bathroom. Taking his bedroom door away, IMO, for the infraction at hand is like using a howitzer to shoot at sparrows. What will you use to shoot at elephants down the road?
Also, he feels alienated, i would guess. Alienating him further is not necessarily the answer.
That is awful SunnyD. Like
That is awful SunnyD. Like you, while growing up my teachers/coaches were considered the pinacles of authority and I never questioned them or challenged them. I did what I was told to do because I was always taught to "respect my elders". I was fortunate though. With the exception of maybe one teacher, all my teachers were very good. I went to a private school and all the teachers there held a Bachelors or a Masters degree in their respective subjects and no teacher had less than 10 years of experience teaching.
DW and I did do a quick background check on the teacher we spoke to last night (the one that SS refused to write the test). Actually DW works with someone who actually had her (she's been teaching at the school for 20 years). According to DW's colleague, she is strict but she knows her stuff and she does a good job preparing her students for the next grade.
Yeah I think there was "gap"
Yeah I think there was "gap" between the lines of communication between the teachers, the councilors and us (the parents). I cannot point the finger at anyone here for where the communication fell apart. SS did perform better overall than last semester so maybe that was why there was no immediate cause to contact us directly? I don't know.
The things is, the counselor
The things is, the counselor DID call and leave a message with Draco's wife. She said that SS had missed a meeting with her to discuss his behavior. Instead of calling the counselor back to find out what was going on, they have SS write a letter of apology to the counselor for missing the meeting.
Counselor gets the letter, thinks SS is going to do better and says it's okay for him to go on the field trip. SS says the meeting is about his behavior in his math class. He says his math teacher is picking on him. But Draco and DW never contact the math teacher or the counselor to find out what's really going on. They're just happy that SS finally did write the letter of apology.
http://www.steptalk.org/node/171771
Draco, I'm not trying to be harsh, here, but it looks like you and your DW dropped the ball on this one. Like I said in my post below, if you're going to be involved in SS's education, you need to be in all the way.
Hindsight is 20/20. Obviously
Hindsight is 20/20. Obviously if we knew then what we knew NOW we would have acted/reacted differently. We just never would have imagined in a million years that SS would be defiant and refuse to write a test! I mean that to me is as unlikely as SS stealing a car and crashing it into a Hooters restaurant. But I suppose anything is possible.
1) He lost his house key and
1) He lost his house key and made no effort to try and find it. I don't blame him (or anyone for losing their house key). Losing their house key and showing absolutely zero accountability for it? THAT, I have a problem with. SS found his key though, so to me that issue is closed.
2) We do not hide anything from Donkeykong. Donkeykong has the same access to all the reports and notes from teachers as we do. In fact, he did actually come to the parent teacher conference last night (we never saw him, but the teachers said he had come), so he knows everything that we know. Unfortunately, Donkeykong made his intentions quite clear to us. He has absolutely no interest in co-parenting with DW. NONE! His only agenda is to get back at us for winning custody. He still acts like a wounded lion and anytime we have tried to communicate with him, he lashes out at us.
3) The only reason why you think I am hard on SS is because you see me as "overstepping my bounds". I would be overstepping my bounds if DW and I didn't communicate and decide what to do beforehand. SS may not be my kid but DW and I have made a commitment to each other to raise SS as a normal (nuclear) family would. There is no division of roles and responsibilities here. We are both equal stakeholders in all our childrens futures.
Draco, If you're going to be
Draco,
If you're going to be involved in your SS's education I think you need to step it up then. Either you're in or you're out.
When the counselor called and said SS didn't show up for a meeting with her, someone should have called counselor and found WHY SS needed to meet with her.
Now that you've found out SS had two lunch detentions, someone needs to let SS's teachers know whenever anything like this happens you need a phone call.
I don't know if SS is deliberately refusing to do his tests, or if he's spacing out or what. The truth is probably somewhere in the middle.
But if you're going to be involved you need to be involved ALL of the way. You need to be checking his homework assignments in the parent portal. And if you notice that a teacher isn't updating the information, you need to call/email her and if she doesn't respond then you need to call/email the principal. SS is 13, teachers aren't going to call home now for every little thing (even though they should have called home about the lunch detentions). At this age the teachers expect the child to be responsible for making sure their homework is done.
I hear you amber. There are
I hear you amber. There are lots of things that DW and I need to do. We're actually going to list them down. SS has a ped day in two weeks. I already made a request with my boss for permission to work from home so I can keep an eye on SS and make sure he tackles these art projects and catches up on his math and reading assignments.
Good for you! Hopefully
Good for you! Hopefully ya'll can turn things around.
I think your DW may benefit
I think your DW may benefit from taking a couple days off work and attending classes with SS. Yeah, kid will be embarrassed to pieces, but who cares. Kid doesn't care what the other kids think when he basically tells teacher to 'FU, I'm not taking your test' , so how SS feels about DW presence as if SS were back in pre-school doesn't concern me.
She needs to see what's going on in the actual setting during actual class time. Who does the kid sit by? Are his friends influencing the poor behavior? Can SS see and hear the teacher? Is the teacher calling out SS more than anybody else during the same class. Does the teacher's teaching manner put the kid in zzzzzzz mode? Is SS taking notes and writing down assignments? Blah blah blah.
Once DW observes quietly from a corner for a day or two and has a chance to experience exactly what her son experiences it, she can confer with the teacher again. Discussing any trigger points or issues she observed that could be feeding the defiant behavior. Is he sitting next to a kid that laughs at SS's BS? Is there a kid distracting SS and a simple move up by teacher's desk might make paying attention easier? How are SS's friends doing with same teacher?
If it truly appears to be a personality conflict between teacher and SS perhaps a change to a different math teacher. It could be the teacher didn't start off 'picking' on kid but by the time teacher has had his fill of defiant behavior and/or slacking off kid both SS and teacher have stopped trying with each other. On the other hand, if it's not a school setting issue or a teacher personality conflict, something else is going on and your wife needs to identify and deal with it whether that is behavioral therapy for SS, school RTI type program or whatever. seriously, DW can discipline SS at home 24/7 but none of it will help what's going on until DW identifies exactly what she's dealing with and why.
^^^^THIS^^^^ great
^^^^THIS^^^^ great suggestions.
SS says one thing, teacher says something else, the truth probably lies somewhere in the middle. I truly don't think SS is just refusing to take the tests for no reason. Maybe the teacher really is picking on him, maybe he's just being lazy, maybe he feels so overwhelmed he doesn't know how to start the test and just sits there staring into space.
Sitting in and observing the class is a great idea. I've done it before and it helped to see exactly what was going on.
no draco dont put words in my
no draco dont put words in my mouth. overstepping is a very small part of what I see.
what i see is the same thing I see here in my own house. you and i take ownership of everything because we are anal and controlling and know what we feel is right. unfortunely that flies with children that are our own, it does not fly when the child is not our own.
an example. and just an example. my dh and your dw are somewhat the same, if they ignore an issue it will go away. so we step up because we are well aware of our spouses down falls so we swoop in and take care of things. I have expectations here it is a c or above average, dh agreed and it has been the rule for 8 yrs. sd gets here at 15 and suddenly a 59 is ok. failing! i pushed and pushed until I finally realized it was a breeding ground for resentment.
the key was an issue Draco, so much so you blogged about it. but even if the key wasnt an issue let me explain this to you most kids dont look for things, esp teenagers. why would they when mom or dad will do it for them.
you can not be a father figure to a kid that has a father.
You're the one straw manning
You're the one straw manning me whatwasithinking. How many times do I have to repeat it? Donkeykong doesn't give a RAT'S ASS if SS fails! I really don't get why a few of you insist I should step back because SS is Donkeykong's property. The only thing Donkeykong cares about is getting revenge for us winning primary custody in court. And again, ONE MORE TIME with feeling....DW and I always, always, ALWAYS talk to each other before enforcing any kind of discipline/ corrective measures with SS.
*guh*