Age children should move out or Contribute
My wife and I have 5 children between us and live in a 4 bedroom house. We have a 23 year old who lives with us. She doesn't help out around the house NEARLY as much as I think is reasonable and she doesn't contribute financially because she doesn't work. And, because of the number of kids and rooms available, we have a 15 year old son sharing a bedroom with us. I've been bringing the issue up for awhile to my wife but she is content to let things continue, only urging me to look for a larger house with more room. To me, a 23 year old needs to move out or contribute financially or with the household work. But my wife thinks I'm "picking on" her daughter. To make things worse, her daughter spends most of her time in her room rarely ever talking or acknowleding my kids at all. I would appreciate honest thoughts that could help me gain perspective here. Thanks.
- Log in to post comments
Your opening comment, "Oh
Your opening comment, "Oh Hell no" says it all. Your advice about launching or becoming the chore bitch was exactly wheat I proposed over a year ago. My wife felt that was "unfair". Unfortuantely, thats a big reason why we're in the situation we're in. Mother will justify, rationalize, or excuse her daughter's behavior and lack of help, and she or somebody else will end up doing the work the daughter won't. It's really an unbelievable thing to witness! UN-BELIEVABLE!
So giving her chores doesn't work. Talking to wife doesn't help because she thinks that simply expecting the daughter to make sure the kitchen is clean when we get home from work is "too much to ask". My next and perhaps final solution is to ask my wife's friends for help. I know they see it. I'm going to ask one of them to say something to my wife.
Can you restrict finances somehow?
Does your wife work? Or are you the main earning spouse? If you can restrict the finances for the 23 yo somehow that will be a definite wake-up call.
Your wife really needs to understand that by enabling her daughter, she is cippling her from a life of richness. Hobbling her. What kind of job is going to let her skate by on doing nothing?
Rags, you are right. The
Rags, you are right. The happiness of the other 6 are being sacrificed to cater to the SD-23.
I raised my neice and when
I raised my neice and when she started college I gave her a car. At first she was great about helping with chores. But she started to slack after SO and SKs moved in with us. I could understand her frustration as SKs are lazy and do not do anything. But, I also wasnt going to let her be a mooch either. So I gave her a choice and a deadline. If she didnt want to help out around the house, then she would get a job and pay rent. She would still be responsible for cleaning up after herself. She chose the job and rent and she does make sure her room is clean and she washes her own dishes and does her own laundry. She also buys her own laundry soap and personal supplies, pays for her own car repairs. Her rent basically covers her car insurance and is put towards groceries. It's not about the money but teaching her to be responsible. I also make her maintain a savings account which I monitor because she will be moving out in a year to go onto get her Bachelor's degree.
love this
Great advice and now I want a house elf lol
Is the ADULT in college? Are
Is the ADULT in college? Are there any plans for launching? At what age does your wife think it would be appropriate for her ADULT to move out?
What are the ages and sexes of the other children? No way a married couple should be sharing with a teenager...
At this point, the discussion should not have anything to do with her contributing to stay... it should be when is she moving out.
The other kids are 18 (moving
The other kids are 18 (moving out slowly as he has a job and is taking college classes), 16, 15, and 9.My wife and I both work. We don't give the 23 year old any money, but she doesn't need it when all her needs are met by the house.
Yes. My wife is enabling and stuntig her growth. I've used the words"learned helplessness" to explain to my wife whats happening.
The 23 year old has been taking online classes for a few years now. But often she drops them without telling anyone. My wife and the 23 year oldt alk about launching but I see no progress.
WHat the step daughter is trying to do is make money by playing games on line and get subscribers. She is in her room 22 hours a day. This is not an exagerration.
Can the kids, INCLUDING the
Can the kids, INCLUDING the 23yr old, share rooms so the teen is not in the adult married couple bedroom?
If miss video game superstar had to share a room, she might get uncomfortable.
Let's face reality. The skidult is not going to grow up on her own - find a job, go to college regularly, etc. It's going to get ugly, real ugly, before it gets better...
It may get to the point of "daughter or me". That might be the only way to get her out.
Bedrooms need to be
Bedrooms need to be reconfigured. There is no way a child over infant stage should be sharing the marital bedroom. SD23 gets her things in cardboard boxes to make her move out simpler.
Change the router password and turn it off when you are not home and after 11pm. If she needs the internet for school, she can use the local library during the day. Make life hard at home.
Thank you all for your
Thank you all for your thoughts and ideas. Many of your suggestions have been made already with no effect. Mother will not enforce. Stepped Out's suggestion, "daughter or me" is the route I'm taking.
Yea... if she chooses you, it
Yea... if she chooses you, it is going to be a long road to let go of the resentment that I can only assume has built.
To be honest, I'm not sure I'd give the choice... I would make it for her.
But then, my bullsh!t bucket is full. Perhaps yours has more room.
15 year old sharing YOUR bedroom????!!!
I never even had a toddler share our bedroom...OH HELL NO
The 15 year old ( SS) was 11
The 15 year old ( SS) was 11 when we moved into this house. The 23 year old was 19 and was supposed to be here for 9 months. After that, the SS was to get her room. This living situation was supposed to be temporary. Now, my wife wants to buy a bigger home so that all the "children" have a room.
Wife told you to look for. Abigger house to accommodate
Princess laziness so everyone can live off you financially?? Yesh thats bad parenting and not at all solving the situation...
Wife contributes. Not 50-50
Wife contributes. Not 50-50 but more like 35-65.But with the rest of the kids getting older and bigger, our resources deplete alot faster than they used too and, obviously, its costing us more. The money factor exacerbates the problem.
You said you moved into her
You said you moved into her home... you aren't paying 65% of a mortgage that you are not on deed, are you?
This all sounds incredibly unfair for you and your children.
No. I bought the house. But
No. I bought the house. But we moved in together. Even though we had 5 kids and only 3 bedrooms between them, I was led to understand that my SD would only be there for 9 months, so the SS would get her room while my 2 girls shared a room and my son got a room. SS didn't want to share a room with my son because he felt room was too small so wife and I agreed to give him space in our room. At that time, he was only there for 2 days a week. But a a couple years ago, he decided to stay with us full time.
Here's where things get interesting
My son is processing out of the house to go live with his mother. He is 18 now, working and going to school. There will be a room available soon. My SS was told years ago that he would get the SD's room when she left. My youngest daughter was promised the room when my son moved out at 18, I want to give it to her. My wife,obviously, wants me to give it to her son. I see the logic behind this, but I still think its unfair.
That's what I believe is
That's what I believe is right. I think my wife agrees, but SS sees that a room will soon be available. Obviously, he wants it, but knows its intended for one of my girls. So thats where the pressure to buy a larger house comes in. And thats why I'm turning the attenton towards SD-23 who is taking up valuable space.
Either sd23 finds her wings
Either sd23 finds her wings or her mom and all her kids can find wings.
This is rediculous and you have been far more accomdating than most people would have been. Time to put your foot down.
Thank you and I agree. It is
Thank you and I agree. It is time to put my foot down.
Wow so your wife basically
Wow so your wife basically wants to buy a larger house, FOR a 23 yo. NOPE.
Part of this is cultural and
Part of this is cultural and part of it is something else. Cuturally,my wife comes from a bckground where the children stay at home until they marry and sometimes even then, they still stay home. Even though that way is changing in her family, my wife still holds to it to a certain degree, but defnitely not full scale.
Another reason is my wife feels guilt. SD-23 becamse depressed after her parents divorced. SD-23 still talks about the effect it had and continues to have on her.
It is a manipulation tactic.
It is a manipulation tactic. Is she seeking therapy for her "COD depression"?
Also, that is your WIFE'S
Also, that is your WIFE'S culture, but not yours... you have compromised by letting her stay this long, now it's her turn to compromise and launch the adult.
I stopped reading after you
I stopped reading after you said that a 15 year old was sharing a bedroom with you and your wife. Nope! Adults need a "child-free" space in the home. Maybe you should force the 23 year old to share her room with the 15 year old. That might inspire her to move out.
When and if my wife and I
When and if my wife and I talk again, I will propose that as a solution. As of right now, my last proposition was for her to leave and move in with either Biological father, or grandparents who have an available room and live just 10 minutes away.
What? There are other optionS
What? There are other optionS available that are reasonable, yet your wife prefers to share your bedroom with her teen?
This makes it 100x worse.
I hate to ask the elephant in the room question... but how the heck are you able to have intimate time with your wife with ss in the room?
Friends have asked the same
Friends have asked the same question. We used to find time when the SS wasn't home, or find other moments when he was occupied elsewhere. Like I said before, initially, he was only there 2 days a week. But since a year or so ago, he's lives here everyday because he didn't want to go back to his biological father's house.
Thank you for your thoughts.
Thank you for your thoughts.
I did give my wife an ultimatum. I told her how detrimental these conditions are for everyone in the house (even SD-23) and either it changes or it's over.
Last night at dinner, SD-23 was at the table and stayed there until everyone finished eating. Usually, she either leaves the table the minute she's done eating, or she takes her food to her room. This time, she stayed till the end, just sitting in her chair not saying a word. Basically, pouting.
BUT, she "cleaned up" like everyone else. I say "cleaned" because while other were clearing the table, sweeping the floor, or putting the dishes away, she... get this... put the bread clip back on the bag of bread and then stood my the table. The moment I closed dinner by commenting that the dining area looks good, she was off to her room.
The point of this story is this: My wife will look at the fact she stayed until dinner and put the bread clip on the bread as "progress". My wife will ignore the fact that she didn't say a word throughout dinner pretty much ignoring everybody except SS-15 (remember, rejection of my family is one of the issues) and that she was pouting (23 years old!). Granted, staying until dinner is good and putting the bread clip on the bread is way more than she ever has done. But am I wrong to see putting the bread clip on as almost a hostile, "in -your-face" type of act??
Thank you
Doing my best to be.
I can even understand how/why
I can even understand how/why she may not like my 16 year old daughter. Their personalities are different and my daughter can throw attitude as well. My son however, is easy going and good tempered but also a slob, and my 9 year old loves everybody but talks alot (In fact, my SS-15 and my kids all get along great. He even knows my relatives very well and he visits with them
For historical purposes, I will identify when things really started to get bad; When my daughter was 13 and SD was 20, my daughter tried SD's makeup that was in the bathroom. Apparently, my daughter ruined it. SD was furious. She told her mother that she felt disrespected because her property was taken without permission. Now I may have made things worse. I agreed that my daughter was wrong, but I didn't take it as serious as SD did (I grew up with 3 brothers and 2 sisters and the concept of private property was almost non-existent. True, I would get mad at my brothers when I couldn't find my stuff or when their incompetence ended up ruining my things, but I also was OK with it for the most part). I felt SD wanted a pound of flesh as compensation. Wife explained that SD wasn't used to this and needed time to get used to it. I told her I understood but also said, "it's just makeup".
Apparently, SD-23 still hasn't forgiven my daughter for it. And wife brings it up whenever we have disagreements about our "family". I admit I will defend my daughter by saying things like "she was 13 for God's sake!" And my wife will use that incident to justify SD's segregation from the rest of us.
It's been over 3 years since this happened. True, on occasions, SD-23 has been nice to my kids. But it's very rare and it's now gotten to the point where if she is nice, it kinda freaks out my kids a bit.
This story is a little background to one of many issues: Rejection of my family. The other main one: laziness and refusal to contribute or help out.
A marriage where a 15 year
A marriage where a 15 year old child sleeps in the marital bedroom is not going to go great. Time to get someone outside of your relationship who your wife will respect to explain to her that this is not normal, necessary or healthy for anyone. Try a religious leader, a therapist, a parent, a best friend...basically anyone as I could not imagine anyone being able to justify this.
Getting the 23 yr old to contriubte or leave the home should be a secondary consideration. Getting the boy out of your bedroom needs to happen asap. Once that is done then you can try to address the 23yr old with your wife.
"Getting the 23 yr old to
"Getting the 23 yr old to contriubte or leave the home should be a secondary consideration."
I feel like I am taking care of a 23-year old and it's sickening to me. Knowing that she's in her room playing games while everyone else is cleaning, cooking, shopping, etc, etc. gnaws at me like nothing else. I've moved beyond being accepting of "contributions" now. I want her to leave.
But if I move my girls into the same room and make them share so that SS15 can have his own room, then mom and SD23 stop feeling any sort of pressure to launch. Right now, the pressure coming from me AND the pressure coming from SS15 to get his own room are the only forces that has mom putting pressure on SD23. Once thats gone, SD-23 is nevering leaving the nest. I reallly believe this.