In need of some good advise and opinions. My husband wants to pay for his adult daughters wedding and I don't agree.
I met my husband 6 yrs ago.He's10 yrs older,3 kids from his previous marriage,1 from before he was married.I have 2 from my previous marriage(So 6 between us)he had his 3 living with him full time.His ex left the state to move in with a man.She sees her kids 1 to 2 times a year.Even though my husband had full custody he still had to pay her $700 a month in alimony.So once we were together we were paying for everything for his kids + her alimony each month.We paid for all his kids needs including first cars &insurance,20,000 out of pocket for his daughters college and his son currently in college.His alimony was for 7 years and ended last year.she has not contributed a thing for these kids!She also collects 750 a month in ssi because she's"depressed and can't work"& whatever her boyfriend makes.Meanwhile we're living in a house that's falling apart and we're supposed to be saving to buy a new home together.I save every penny & sacrifice many things to do so.I drive a 14yo truck while his kids have much newer cars,now his daughter is getting married.She is 24,will be 25.She has lived with her boyfriend going on 5 years with a child.My husband tells me today he plans to pay for it.I thought we we're going to pay for the pics and/or flowers(a couple thousand)I feel like my children & I r getting the short end of the stick.I know we will not be paying for the other kids weddings & he didn't pay for his daughters wedding from his first relationship.Am I wrong for feeling this way?
Advice*
Advice*
Many kids are paying for
Many kids are paying for their weddings. Do some research on-line about this subject and show him how its a dying custom.
It's nothing more than another way of paying a dowry. Selling a bride - paying money to the grooms family to get rid of her (now they don't have to pay half. Worthless females. The girl should be insulted.
Half of them are practice weddings anyway in that they'll end up in divorce.
I actually did just that. I
I actually did just that. I showed him articles about modern weddings. His opinion is it's his daughter so he should pay. He Ifeels that I'm being selfish and a bad parent. He feels we should do anything and everything for the kids. He doesn't get the fact that it's unfair being that we could never pay for all the kids weddings and that it is also not right that we are living in a horrible house and are supposed to be saving to buy a new home together.
I know his heart is in the
I know his heart is in the right place with his daughter but I wish he could see how it's wrong to do tonme and my children.
My husband makes a
My husband makes a good
Submitted by Jen_h on Fri, 06/06/2014 - 1:44am.
My husband makes a good living but after paying for all of those things it is very hard to save any money. I have a good amount saved from before I was with him but it is not the full amount we will need for the 20 percent needed to put down on our new house.
I oppose it because I've been waiting a few years now for us to buy a home together and I also think it's wrong to pay for one child's wedding if you can't pay for all the children's weddings.
I do own it, it was a home I
I do own it, it was a home I rented out years ago but when I got divorced from my first husband I had no choice to to move into it
My husbands children are all
My husbands children are all adults, my youngest child just turned 16,.. How will we afford to get him a new car, pay for his college or pay for any of the other children's weddings? It can't always just be about his 3. He has another daughter and I have 2 children. If we're doing everything together as husband and wife how is that right?
Ps his daughter has not asked
Ps his daughter has not asked him to pay for the entire wedding nor do I think she expects him to. I'm sorry but if we are married and do everything together it should be a joint decision and I find nothing wrong with expecting a 25 year old that has been living with this man to pay for part of the wedding and I feel her father, mother and the grooms family should help. not just my husband who has other children and a wife to also think about
I don't believe your feelings
I don't believe your feelings are wrong or unwarranted. you married believing that you would share a future and make those decisions together (and rightly so). but, he is still living his single life where finances were his own. that's not the case any more. you are going to have to put your foot down here. tell him he's already spent more of your joint money on his kids and ex than will ever happen with your kids. fair is fair and enough is enough. if you cannot get him to see reason, you need to split your finances asap. see what he can afford on his own. do not touch the savings you have accumulated yourself to go towards this. tell him that you will not allow him to bankrupt your marriage so that his kids can have the best of everything. they're grown, making adult decisions and have a family of their own. if they want to get married, they can pay for it. and I have to say that if he was expecting to pay for this wedding, he should have saved for it.
You feel like you’re getting
You feel like you’re getting the short end of the stick because you are! I just wrote a long response but it didn’t stick but bottom line- the bride and groom need to plan a wedding they can afford. I think it would be a nice gesture to contribute something relatively inexpensive like the flowers or a dress under 1k, but there is no way in hell anyone should go into debt or use the money they have saved for a house for a wedding. My DH and I got married 2 years ago and no one in our family offered to help financially, so we went away just the 2 of us. We couldn’t/didn’t want to spend thousands and thousands of dollars to entertain other people when we could go away for a fraction of the cost and use that money on more important things.
So he paid his ex wife
So he paid his ex wife alimoney when she was shacking up with a man in another state? And did she ever have to pay child support to your husband or did she give up the kids?
I don't see a problem with
I don't see a problem with your DH wanting to pay all or most of her wedding. I do think she should contribute... be it 1/2 or a %.
I agree with LadyFace and think you've got a bit of a double standard going here.
Honestly, I don't think
Honestly, I don't think either of you is "wrong". It's not even about whether it's reasonable for a father to pay for his daughter's wedding, if he wants to and has the money. The actual problem is that you think you should have veto power over that decision, and he doesn't. You're not at all on the same page about "how do we decide what to spend money on?". THAT is the issue you need to address.
You don't mention if you work or not, but if you don't then you're in a much weaker position to demand that you have power to decide what he spends money on. You're completely within your rights to demand that YOUR money not be spent on a wedding, if you're helping contribute to that savings. But it sounds like your DH sees money more as "yours -vs- mine" while you see it all as co-mingled.
Let me ask you something. Let's say you wanted to use some money that you'd saved (however you saved it) to buy your son a new car, and your DH said you weren't allowed to for whatever reason. What would your reaction be? Does that make it at all easier to see where your DH is coming from? Because you BOTH need to be able to see each other's view points if you're going to discuss this. (And to get your DH to understand it, ask him how he would feel if, instead of using your savings to help buy a house, you spent it all on your kids instead.)
the short version of my
the short version of my advice: If you share finances, you need to have shared financial goals. If you can't have shared financial goals, you need to have separate finances.
the longer version:
You two need to get on the same page with regard to finances. My advice: put the SD wedding aside for a minute and just sit down with your budget and figure out how much money is left over at the end of the month / year whatever that is not needed for your retirement, living expenses and other large forecast outflows (like your new house down payment, or if one of you needs a new car). Then take a look at the amount that's left over and see how much of it you think makes sense to spend on the kids, and start discussing how it should be spent. And try to understand and have compassion for where he's coming from - there are a lot of cultural narratives around the "father of the bride" and he's probably feeling indirect/implicit social pressure to show he's a provider / good dad / "real man" etc. But there should be room for compromise between what he wants and want you see can really be afforded, go into the discussion remembering you are partners on the same team, and believing you will find a number you can both be satisfied with.
I feel your pain, it's so hard to be in agreement when you feel like your kids are literally in competition with his for financial resources. I don't have kids, but I sometimes feel like I am in competition with the kids for financial resources. There's only so much money to go around and even if there were only two of us in the relationship, it's still a lot of communication and negotiation to spend the money fairly.
Good luck and keep us posted!