Asking For Opinions
How much should a bio dad know about his 21 y/o daughter's birth control and menstrual cycle?
I'm from an older generation where "women things" weren't discussed in front of or with dads. Of course, periods needed to be shared with boyfriends, fiances, and husbands. How to prevent kids, how to conceive them. I would have died before I talked about my period with my dad.
I get it's a different world now, but I don't need to hear how "Daughter called because she needs more tampons, and get her shot even though she's away at college." I don't need to hear that at brunch or at dinner!
I know I will likely get heat from this, but I think it's just weird. Help me understand.
- IDontCare3117's blog
- Log in or register to post comments
Comments
I think it's weird. I'm 48,
I think it's weird. I'm 48, so not sure where I fall on the older or younger spectrum, but I never discussed things like that with my own father. He probably didn't want to know all of that. He might have picked up pads for me at the store if needed but that would be the extent of it. I honestly don't remember him doing that, but my parents divorced when I was 12 and I lived with my mom. I was close to my dad too.
In my household, my husband has no problem talking to me about my period, but doesn't want to hear about our daughter's. My daughter doesn't ever bring it up in front of my husband either because she would feel weird.
My SIL, on the other hand, wants to involve my brother in all of that talk about my niece and her cycle. She even told me that I should want to hear about my daughter's sex life if she had one. But I consider the source on that one. My SIL is certifiably crazy for reasons that have nothing to do with this topic.
I'm 53 - yeah, I know I'm
I'm 53 - yeah, I know I'm older than dirt. My SO is 63. He had his first daughter when he was 24. He had the one I'm asking about when he was in his early 40s. Twenty years apart for his kids I have no problem with any of that.
I would have died a thousand deaths before my dad actively knew about my cycle or birth control. He didn't want to know, and I certainly didn't want him to know.
I would never in a million
I would never in a million years have had discussed anything of that nature with my father
DH only got involved if he
DH only got involved if he needed to pick up supplies for OSD (YSD does not ever ever ever bring it up with either of us. She must bring supplies from BMs because she won't even use the stash I have in the 2nd bathroom she uses) or OSD needed Advil or Premarin for cramps.
Depends on what kind of man
Depends on what kind of man he is.
If he's truly trying to help his daughter (and she is unknowledgable for her age and/or doesn't have a woman she trusts to discuss reproductive topics) that's one thing but if tracking her cycles is a thinly veiled attempt to control her/poke his nose where it doesn't belong then that's out of order and bordering on putting her into the position of mini-spouse imo
Most men want to know about cycles of their partners so they can easily figure out when they can have relations, when a missed cycle could be a pregnancy, and when to stay out of the way/avoid being annoying if the lady has PMS
Theyd only want to know this about their daughters if they're underage and trying to prevent teenage pregnancies or teach them about their own bodies to prepare them for adulthood
Not something you'd typically think an already adult woman and her dad would do. But some people feel like they need to know everything about their offspring.
I'm 41, never discussed any
I'm 41, never discussed any of that with my dad. It just wasn't really done when I was a young girl/woman.
OSD is very open with XH, hasn't ever overshared in my opinion, but also hasn't shied away from being direct about those topics if it was relevant. YSD is much more reserved and I don't think she's ever even asked him to buy tampons.
DD10 is MUCH more open and direct than either of them, she literally has no embarrassment about talking about anything with either XH or me. That could change with puberty, but at this stage she will casually ask questions about reproduction or sex to whichever one of us she happens to be with when the question occurs to her. I honestly don't hate it, I think there is a lot of value in being comfortable and confident enough to discuss those topics with the opposite gender.
I'm 59. DH and I were at SD28
I'm 59. DH and I were at SD28's house recently and she was "under the weather". IOW, she was having her period, talked about it with me, but didn't want to discuss it with her dad because (her word), "Ew!" So I think it's weird for a 21yo to give that much detail to her dad.
Well.. it's not dinner table
Well.. it's not dinner table conversation.. haha... but I think that it's probably a good thing that his daughter is comfortable talking about BC with her father.. because it shows some maturity that she is caring for her own body in appropriate ways.
My YSD has no "shame" about discussing medical type things.. even surrounding her reproductive health.. with me.. and her dad is aware of it also (she also has some migraine issues along with epilepsy.. so things can be intertwined.. so not totally unrelated)
Sorry, ESMOD, I've got to
Sorry, ESMOD, I've got to disagree. Why does an adult female need to let her father know about her BC or that she needs tampons, pads, or anything else to manage a period?
Just the need for Supplys.
Someone was needed to pay for $ampons
That's kind of what I was
That's kind of what I was thinking the only rationale I could see for being this far into his adult daughter's reproductive health is if she is on his insurance and running birth control claims through his insurance then he probably thinks he has the right to know everything
a bit much imo but eh not my moneys not my show
Is she texting asking for
Is she texting asking for money when she talks about it? Maybe she thinks that's w way to get him to "shut up and pay" because he will be so uncomfortable he won't ask any further questions.
My SO's daughters, 24 and 27, are like this. One of them called him once for money to go to the ER. She said "I have a UTI Daddy! My vagina burns soooo bad even though i always pee after sex!"
Another one called for money for clothes. "My cup size is up to a DD!! Please!!!"
EW for what your SDs did.
EW for what your SDs did.
He's not uncomfortable, but I don't think he realizes, at a certain point, some shit between fathers and daughters doesn't need to be shared. To me, it's...just...not...appropriate.
OMG...I thought it was just my SD's
It makes me cringe when my DH has them on speaker phone and they talk about this. Hell, we were once in a car eldest SD on speaker talking about her heavy flow full well knowing that not only was I there but hubby's best friend as well. I'm old school came from a family of 4 girls and could never imagine any of us talking about it with my Dad. We were not a family of prudes but some things are just private. Unless, there was an emergency my Dad did'nt need to hear about it.
To provide a little context:
To provide a little context:
- She did and does have a mother who is involved in her life even though mom and dad are divorced. They split when she was a preteen. I can understand dad having to make the occasional drug store run before she was old enough to drive herself. Now? Not so much.
- She's 21 and 2 hours away from dad at college. I don't understand why she would need or want her dad's assistance in getting her BC shot or Lady Supplies. At 21, I was remembering to take that tiny pill every day all on my own. I sure as hell wasn't involving my father in my sex life or reproductive system.
- I see this as somewhat a lack of boundaries between a father and daughter. Something ain't right when a daughter thinks it's okay to ask her dad what his "body count" is. That's creepy to me.
-
I see this as somewhat a lack
I concur ... but didn't want to say myself to prevent from inadvertently ffending you
Unless he's a gynecologist, she's developmentally delayed, or in the ER with some major reproductive issue that will cost oodles of money or something and really needs to know what's going bc she's on his insurance/he has to drop some coins .... it's a tad bit much IMO
Typically most girls and women will ask moms, step moms, aunts, grandmas, female teachers, anyone except a man who typically has less of a clue about a woman's body than we do
No offense taken for anything
No offense taken for anything you've posted on my blog.
Daughter asked father his
Daughter asked father his "body count"?! *bad*
When he told me she'd asked
When he told me she'd asked him about his body count, I immediately poured a triple shot of Jager and began googling the receipe for Mind Bleach.
I highly recommend a Mind
I highly recommend a Mind Eraser or two.
https://www.thespruceeats.com/mind-eraser-vodka-shot-761115
I'll take a pitcher of those,
I'll take a pitcher of those, please!
Again, ew, weird. When I got
Again, ew, weird. When I got to a certain age I naturally gravitated a little more towards my mom. Periods were discussed with Mom, birth control, Mom. Dad, as far as I know, didn't know I was on birth control. It was hinted at after I was married but he probably already assumed I was on birth control after I got married. Mom felt it was none of his business. My husband doesn't even want to know that our daughter has periods and probably wouldn't want to know if she was on birth control, which she isn't. Most men probably don't want to hear about things of that nature about their daughters, sisters, mothers, etc. My son I'm sure doesn't want to be in the room if my daughter and I are talking about it. He walks off if my mom and I start talking about Perimenopause. They don't want to know. Their wives are different but you start talking about their daughters, sisters or mothers, they don't usually want to know. About anything. Periods,birth control, menopause, nothing.