You are here

Need some advice, how old is old enough to explain

mckenzie0806's picture

things to a Step/Bio Child. My SD10 is kind of immature for her age. She has been diagnosed with ADHD (is doing great thanks to meds!) and probably has some sort of PTSD from being physically abused by her BM. We found out last week that BM has been showing her all of the text messages that DH has sent to BM. Some of these were not so nice like when BM would not let DH talk to his daughter on her 10th bday, or when BM refuses to pay medicals or let DH talk to his daughter on BM's weekends. DH and I sat down with SD10 last night and tried to explain to her the situation. That any kind of ugliness was between DH and BM. I do not understand why the BM would show the SD10 these messages anyway. SD10 said that her mother will just hand her the cell phone and say, "See what your Daddy said about me?"

We NEVER say anything about the BM in front of SD10. Never. Anytime she wants to call her mom we absolutely let her. However, SD10 started crying when DH was explaining this to SD. Like she was afraid of her father. We asked her if she remembered what happened to her that she came and lived with us. She said that she did not remember anything about the abuse, the police, DCS or anything. Do we explain that to her? I am just at a loss and need some advice...

Comments

BMJen's picture

he was 4 he's been filling his head with crap about me. It's stupid, uncalled for, and you can take her to court for this mess. She's starting PAS. Watch out, it is a messy road.

I don't know how you can explaine this to her. And I wouldn't. Not at this age, not if she's immature. Take her to thearpy. They can help this situation without you coming out on the wrong end of this stick.

PAS parents tend to fill the kid's head with crap about the other parent. when the other parent tries to defend themselves and tell the kid the TRUTH, they come out looking like the idiot liars. Watch out....

mckenzie0806's picture

we have known for years now that PAS was in effect. However, it is something that the courts here in TN rarely agree with. Last night I really really wanted to pull out pictures of the bruises and the police report and just say, "I was the one who took care of you after your BM did this to you." Of course, DH was deployed when all of this happened. I am making some calls today to professionals because apparently talking to the school counselor isnt going to be enough. To top it all SD is such a sweet, loving, beautiful girl. She just needs help.

honeybunszer's picture

That she was nervous and thought she was in trouble. Even though she is ten, and even if she thinks at a 10 year old's capacity, when a child is "Sat down" to talk it is intimidating. That's not to say it shouldn't be done, but it's probably even more intimidating with two people. Maybe you should try talking to her one on one and just asking questions in an inconspicuous manner. If she is afraid of dad for whatever reason just ask her things like "would you feel more comfortable talking to me?" Just don't make it seem like you're trying to get anyone in trouble or like she HAS to tell you anything. Maybe try drawing with her and ask her to draw something she's afraid of, then something that she likes to do, and i know it might sound silly but it can open up alot of not only comfort for her with you, but also ideas and opportunities for you to ask her "What is this?" or "This is what scares me" or things like that and you might get to see why she's so uncomfortable.

"Everyone is entitled to be stupid, but some abuse the privilege"

mckenzie0806's picture

a fact that she was nervous. BD is military and pretty strict and straight to the point. But I did tell her over and over that she was not in trouble. I made sure that I got down on the floor on her level and talked very calmly to her. We have tried everything. I called and set her up an appointment with a child psychologist but the 1st appt is for BM and BD only. Oh Lord have mercy do i wish i could be a fly on that wall. She's been seeing the school counselor for a while and the school counselor had NO IDEA about the abuse.

sunshine's picture

we could write a book couldnt we LOL. I am really shocked that SD can not remember the events that occurred with BM. It hasnt been that long ago has it. Maybe she choses to not remember or maybe BM has told her to not talk about it.

How old is old enough to explain? Thats a hard question because I think it does depend on the situation and the child. I feel I can talk to BD15 about anything but BD12 I cant. But BD12 has been through some recent tradgic events that has caused alot of friction with her dad. ANd I have been very honest with BD12 and she also is old enough to see what is taking place.

I dont bad mouth her father well maybe I have a time or time and called him a name or two, when I should not have. lol

But your BM has been very immature for years about parenting and handling things with your DH therefore causing consitant drama. I wish you luck and I pray for you.

Also Thank you for being there for me. Your the bestest!!

mckenzie0806's picture

lives sweetie. lol. It was a little over a year ago that all of that happened with her mom and the police and everything. So not that long ago. DH actually wanted me to come to the office to get the pics of her bruises and show them to her. I told him no.

Your girls are like ours, BD11's dad has had some issues and gone to jail and I completely explained it to her. She is mature enough to know the difference. But SD10 is totally different. Like yours.

As for being there for you, I always will be. You are my sista from anutha mutha. Smile

stepmom2one's picture

I wouldn't tell her yet. I think letting her know "something" happened was more than enough.

Let her know that BM should not be showing those things to her, that people say mean things when they get angry sometimes. I would try to explain why people get nasty, how to handle it or how it could be handled better next time.

Your H should be careful of his texts now---but I am sure he is now that he knows what BM is setting him up for.

belleboudeuse's picture

Do you guys think there's ever a good time to explain to a skid about the manipulation going on with their Bioparent? I wonder about this a lot. One of my SDs is 15, she's adopted, she has tons of issues like PTSD, she's in a group home, and her mom hates her. She gets along much better with her dad and me. But last weekend, for example, DH called her at the group home to see how she was, and she refused to come to the phone, saying "We're fighting." (she and her dad). We hadn't seen her since her last home visit with her mom, and DH had no idea there was anything wrong. So we think that BM said something bad about DH (and probably me) to score points with SD15, probably so that the people at the group home would hear about it and think BM was the hero and we are awful.

BM and DH's parenting agreement says they will not speak ill of each other to either of their daughters, but we're pretty sure BM violates this regularly. So, my question is, how do you judge when explaining BM manipulation is okay, and when it's "speaking ill" of the other person?

BB

- You are not second best, you are not second class. Do not ever let anyone make you feel that way. (2Bloved)

Nymh's picture

My take is, it is never our place to "explain" to the children in plain english that what their other parent does is wrong. Instead, we use those things as a learning experience. "Sometimes people get angry with each other and say things they shouldn't. Have you ever said something when you were angry that you regretted?" "Sometimes when you say something to someone, they might take it completely differently from how they intended. Have you ever said something to someone who didn't understand what you were trying to say? How did that make you feel?"

I think that now would be a good time for your DH to realize what is going on and keep all communication professional and emotionless with BM from now on. We all know that these things shouldn't be shared with a 10 year old, but if she's already doing it, you don't need to give her more ammunition.

I am in TN too and we were told that unless BM was beating SS or putting him in overt physical danger, nothing could be done about her parenting and we would never get full custody. Unfortunately our court system is so biased toward BM's that they are allowed to keep the children when every evidence points to them not being fit or capable to raise and take care of them healthfully and properly. Though I am suprised with the history of physical abuse, that custody was not taken away from your SD's BM. Maybe the courts are even more biased than I thought.

*~So sayeth Nymh~*

mckenzie0806's picture

of my SD10. It is HIGHLY unusual for BD's in Tn to get custody. The abuse wasn't the only thing though. BM has neglected SD10's needs for quite some time now. She moves every 6 months, SD has been in 5 different schools at then age 9, BM has live-ins and had let SD sleep in the same bed with her and her live-in BF. The Judge did not like those things at ALL, said he thought DH could better provide for SD educationally and emotionally.

I dont want to "lay all of the cards on the table" per say for SD. We ended up saying all of the things you said to her. I just want to know when will she realize that her mother is manipulating her only to make us (BD and SM) miserable. And it works. lol.

As for your situation, there doesn't have to be abuse or drugs every single time to change custody, you just have to prove a change in circumstance effecting the child!!! Thanks for the chat! Smile

Rags's picture

Talk on the phone and record your calls. We have not had written communication with BioDad in more than a decade except for specific demands or letters written by our Attorneys.

For calls you cannot record keep a Call Log that tracks dates, times, topics and comments made by you and the Blended Family opposition. The key here is to keep your cool and not let them get you to blow your top. Learn to use key wording like "When you can call me back and discuss this as a rational adult. Until then, this conversation is over" CLICK! Then write the Call Log entry in your magic court journal.

It has worked for us and has come in very handy in front of a Judge on more than one occasion. It is the difference in who the Judges believes in a He Said/She Said situation.

The Journal, court reporter minutes and taped telephone calls also help an older Skid gain clarity on the facts of the situation. "Here, read and listen for yourself and form your own opinion" is much healthier for the kid you and your marriage than "Well, do you know what your Mom/Dad said" or "That's a lie this is what was said ......."

But for absolutely sure you don't want to loose your cool in a written or verbal communication. It can come back to bite you with your (S)kids, XW/XW and with the court.

Best regards,

mckenzie0806's picture

calls. However, written communication is the ONLY communication we can have with the BM. She refuses to answer the phone at any time. No matter if SD is with us, or with BM. We also do certified mail. She is just a flat out pain I swear.

Rags's picture

and of course keep your cool.

E-mail lets you archive and print the entire chain of discussion to show to a judge or to your Skids when they are old enough to form their own opinion.

As for what age it is appropriate to give the archives to your (S)kid, that depends on the kid.

Some can handle it earlier than others. However, I would not do it until the kid is in their early to mid teens at the earliest.

Best regards,