How to politely keep my distance and discourage dh's intrusive "step"daughter?
Dh has a daughter he considers like a stepdaugher from a former relationship. Him and his ex gf dated from the time she was a baby up until age 5. They broke up and his "SD" recontacted him at age 15. In foster care. At 18 she became pregnant. Said she was giving the baby up for adoption-ended up keeping baby. She was supposed to make an appt but didn't and ended up losing her home (had something to do with her foster situation). Asked to stay with us, supposedly so she wouldn't lose her kid. Dh wanted to, gave me these reasons...her "needing to save money" even though she worked (how could she save money if she has to commute like that, and I told dh she could pick up more hours), she "wouldn't need to stay long" (first off I didn't buy that for a second and seconly even if it was true she wouldn't need to stay long then there wasn't much of a "need" to begin with, much less a dire one). I also let dh know that she should've followed through with giving the kid up for adoption if she wasn't prepared for motherhood. When the baby was still a newborn she wanted us to keep him overnight, which dh said no. When she wanted to stay with us, dh told me he told her we didn't have room. I found out that he'd messaged her and said that if it was just him he'd let her stay. Needless to say I felt very thrown under the bus.
She contacted me via messenger when she wanted to come see dh, saying she's his daughter (she's not by biology or even marriage) and can I let him know she's trying to get ahold of him? I felt very uncomfortable with her messaging me and it seemed pushy to me. I ignored the message even though I was able to see it, I didn't have to "accept" the message. She sent me some GIF for mothers day and tried to friend me. I blocked her.
This was AFTER her trying to stay with us so why in the WORLD would she try to contact and friend me? I detect something fishy but cannot pinpoint what.
Yesterday dh was looking for a ride to pick up a cheap dining room table. She pops on there and says she has one daddy waddy can have...dh said he already had the table picked up (after he posted) so she starts in on how she's gonna buy him one, AFTER poor dh is hinting that no we're ok but thank you!!
I get a sense that she doesn't know proper boundaries but idk how to explain it to dh, because he's overly attached to her and vice versa,
If she buys this at Christmas and drops it off, do I go in my room so she understands I am uncomfortable? Or stay and send her on her merry way after an hour?? I really don't want a relationship with her...trying to move in with us was a huge turnoff to wanting to get to know her on any level.
That extra table might make a
That extra table might make a great outdoor table for your patio. Let the weather rot it away if Dh can't find his balls.
There is no patio, and it
There is no patio, and it wouldn't do any good to say no to the table if dh insists in taking it. I hope she doesn't buy it.
Tell DH you do not want the
Tell DH you do not want the table in YOUR home. If he gets angry. so be it. You have some say in your own home, the daughter does not control what goes in or out of your domain.
How would you respond to the
How would you respond to the inevitable "she just wants to do something NICE that's so NICE of her" B.S.? I don't understand why she's so attached to dh or what she's hoping to gain buy buying a stinking table. I don't understand either, why she was trying to friend me on fb or message me. I wish I knew how to discourage her or get dh to see how pushy she is.
No, I do not want the table
No, I do not want the table in my house; I do not want her "being nice" to me. You can take the table and put it elsewhere, but it is not going in my home. "Being nice" takes a lot more effort than sharing a table. Neither of you need to insult my intelligence.
There are some things that
There are some things that are personal. For adults, one of those things is furniture. It is your home. You and DH decide what furniture goes in it.
If you were young newly weds with nothing then gift furniture might be appropriate.
In this case it is just weird and smells fishy.
Agree completely! How should
Agree completely! How should I respond to her if she shows up with it? I can't physically stop dh from accepting this table. It smells weird and fishy to me too...how should I explain that part to dh? Seems like something weird is going on with her here...can't quite put my finger on what.
I suggest that you inform DH
I suggest that you inform DH that you will not be accepting the gift table unless it fits your personal decor tastes. Or better yet, just tell him that it will not be in your home. If she shows up with it, it goes in the garage until garbage day or you can call Salvation Army to come pick it up.
Do not deal with SD at all. Inform your DH.
This, absolutely
I had to threaten the garbage once to prevent unwanted food from being brought to a party in my home. DH whined and moaned when I told him I didn't want the contribution. Finally I said, Fine, let her bring it. I'll thank her politely and then take it straight out to the garbage. I would have done exactly that, and he knew it. He decided it would be preferable to phone the person and tell her not to bring the unwelcome contribution.
The moral of the story is, know your boundaries and be prepared to enforce them. You don't want the table, you don't accept it, and you certainly do not make a place for it in your home.
The thing is, once a person gives you something, that thing is yours and you're free to do with it what you will. In this regard I often think of a story about a woman who was widely known to be active in PETA, abhorred people wearing furs, etc. One Christmas her daughter-in-law gifted her a full-length mink coat. Meow. The PETA woman thanked her profusely, dripped gratitude, etc. She made sure the daughter-in-law found out when she sold the coat and donated the proceeds to PETA.
This sort of thing can be amusing for those who have the taste for it.
It sounds like she wants to
It sounds like she wants to put a big chunk of furniture in your house to anchor her presence there. Something to remind *daddee* of how good and generous she is when she needs something from him. She's grasping for family and DH is obliging her and she's reaching out to you.. If she was in a foster home she and her mother are probably not close and it sounds like her bio father had nothing to do with her. DH feels special and needed by this young woman who he has a loose connection to.
DH really needs to define what kind of relationship he wants with her and then set boundaries around that. She sounds very needy and looking for a father but does he really want/need that kind of relationship, or is this just a novelty for him that will wear off soon? There are non bio related people I consider family, but distant, like cousins. If they ever started unloading theri crap on me they'd be demoted further down the family line
If she does haul the table over and you hate it, let DH deal with it and tell her to haul it away. "It's lovely but we just don't have the room. Boo."
Dh wants a relationship with
Dh wants a relationship with her...he did seem to be trying to politely discourage her from buying it, and she kept insisting. Dh won't tell her to haul it away...the best I can hope for is to hope to help wear the thing out sooner than later. She wants to buy a new one to upgrade us fromt he used one dh picked up. Trying to figure out how to act if she comes here and drops the thing off...I don't want to encourage her but if I act too cold-shouldered dh will paint me out to be the bad guy. I'm guessing you are referring to the messaging and friending me with reaching out to me. What I don't get is why she would message me a 2nd time if I didn't accept the first message. AFTER trying to stay with us. Is she really so dense she can't comprehend the fact that trying to plant her and her kid (who she's since given up, and I want to tell her go spend her money on her kid) kind of turns me off to wanting to get to know her? Maybe I should remind dh of that? Other than the moving in thing, though, idk how to explain my uneasiness to dh cuz he doesn't see it as to why I don't desire a relationship with her.
I believe you've got this
I believe you've got this nailed, Still.
You tell her "NO". Do not
You tell her "NO". Do not wait, stop the table now! You have already been blamed, go for it. You tell her, then tell DH you did it. Just be civil, but FIRM. It's better to be blamed, then to ask for permission; it is over, before the argument begins, then you can walk away from the argument. You have it behind you.
I also tell my adult skids no, when DH thinks he cannot. I just forced DH to tell SS54 he could not come stay with us, a few days ago. This was a first for me. I decided it was DH's turn to say "NO ".
Yes, I am to blame, I don't care, and I truly mean that.
Also have them keep it out of your home entirely. My DH is totally disabled, thus his adult kids come to visit, maybe three times a year. I have no problem with their visits, I never host them in any way, but I never deny their visits; I never leave my home with that said. If DH was able, I would suggest they go out to visit, it is not the case.
Take control of the problem, it won't be solved by your DH.
How did you force him?
How did you force him?
He's not being forced; you
He's not being forced; you are......."they" are forcing YOU. Think about it, this will keep happening over and over --if you allow it. After a few times of being used by other people who do not like you or appreciate you being around (includes your DH); you realize YOU are all you have to protect yourself from this on-going bs. Be part of the solution.
Once DH throws us under the bus, from what I have learned; he and he alone ruins any hope of reuniting the family tree, 99 percent of the time. I bet if you surveyed all the women here, you would find our DH's shared marital issues and talked trash to brats all too eager to hear it and share it-- about us at some point, then everything went downhill. DD gains power over the wife that she plans to never relinguish, at that point. There is no turning back for us or DH. Loyalty is everything in a family.
If DH has the nerve to bring that table in your house after you have told him no; call Goodwill for an immediate pick up. You might have to make husband angry to protect yourself....bottom line. He is not trying to please YOU, only his DD....DD has no say in your home and you have boundaries. You would feel much differently if you had been treated/considered respected family from the get go. You need peace and respect in your own home and DH can either respect that or go live with DD, whom he is more eager to please at this time. DH needs the lesson more than DD.
Take the table and you will eventually regret it; a couch is coming in at Christmas....:-)
I asked how the previous
I asked how the previous poster forced her dh. I am very tempted to schedule a pickup for the thing if she brings it. Dh and I haven't discussed the table other than me telling him I think it's strange and he says how nice of her it is to do it. Idk how to explain to dh why I feel the way I do.
You should not have to
You should not have to explain anything to your DH regarding this table. Even if SD is just being nice what comes into your home is up to you. Both you and DH have VETO rights on the contents of the home and the one who says no trumps the one who says yes IMHO.
Do not let this play out. End it now. Before the table shows up.
Marking her territory
I would explain to DH that this is a 'b*tch dog' thing - marking their their territory - and you will not allow it in your house. If DH allows it, you will have to take over and tell SD you would rather decorate your home as you want and she can do the same in her own home without any interference from you. It is your right and as awful as it is sometimes we have to fight for our rights.
Sounds like the most
Sounds like the most plausible explanation...though why she's so intent on marking her territory when she's never lived with us and has visited the house a grand total of once is beyond me.
Territory
She is marking her territory by letting you know she is the alpha in your home and in her relationship with her Father . I can guarantee she is not going to like it when you tell her "No" but you must let her know where her role is. I had an acquaintance who did this to me once. Came over to my home for an event and wanted to rearrange my furniture during the event. I had to tell her more than once to please leave it alone before I had to raise my voice a bit to get the message across - that this was my home and she was infringing on my boundaries. She was mad at me for a while but 'Oh well'! Your SD might not like it either but she must know this will not work for you and this is your home. Maintain your boundaries.
How do I respond do dh when
How do I respond do dh when he goes on and on and howls about how niiiiice she's being? And how if I get rid of the thing (if she buys it) how her feelers are gonna be sooooo HURT if we get rid of it?
Poit out that if she were
Poit out that if she were truly just being nice she wouldn't buy something that she'd already been told you don't want/need. Then ask him why anyone would do such a thing.
Tell him what about your
Tell him what about your feelings and what you want, they count too. You don't want the d@mn table in your house so what is so difficult to understand. Stand firm and DO NOT allow this table in your home. You can't be afraid to say No. Next thing you know she's going to want to get you sofa's and a bedroom set......
Tell SD thanks but no thanks!
OP, this poster is from a
OP, this poster is from a while ago. How did things play out?
Yikes!
It is an old post. Note to self: Check dates before responding. Still, the fact that so many people are still clicking on this a couple of years after the original post indicates evergreen interest in the topic.
Meet the new boss, same as the old boss.