You are here

Tigers don’t change their stripes

greyskies's picture

StepTalkers,

I really have had it dawn on me that our SKs are most likely already out the womb who they are.  Research and experience implies such as well.  Yes, the good old nature vs nurture.  Both are important and contributory.  Of course, certain circumstances and environments can further shape a person, but what differentiates the twin study where one twin grew up to become a millionaire, successful with a loving family, and the other an impoverished drug addict following in his father's footsteps. 

After my experiences assisting raising and monitoring my SKs, one of them has made barely any progress.  The other has made strides in many ways but not much personality wise.  I understand kids are still developing and may come into their own later on, but by around age 10, I think most kids solidify who they are personality wise.

I had a lot of adversarial experiences growing up.  I to this day am still generous, kind, loving, caring.  It is who I am at my core.  We are wired to be able to evolve and change with a little work, but I am still who I am.

I am convinced just some kids are born wrong and wired wrong.  No amount of lecturing, yelling, kind platitudes, advice, support, kicking to the curb, you name it will help.  Goes in one ear out the other.  Some people are just wired to be self destructive and drag others down with them.  Some people are just wired to think they're godly and worldly, and treat others around them like scum unless they are directly benefiting from them.  Some people are just plain lazy and fine being hoarders despite education on why not to be and how to be hygienic.  Some people just want to be miserable and find a scapegoat.  Yes, EVEN KIDS!!! 

My whole worldview has changed being a child free step figure.  And I am sure the genetics with some of these family ties are not helpful.  I read so many stories on here of hoarder/mentally unstable/trashy/foul/criminal bio-parents.  Yes, again, some can be born into such negative circumstances but be better and do better.  But some just don't see a reason to.  They follow in the footsteps and are almost proud of themselves.  They elicit a condescending mannerism.  They think they're better than everyone.  They think they know so much.  They love being the perpetual victim.

This may be an unpopular opinion for the modern masses of "gentle parenting," (which, when applied in their poor taste, is just PERMISSIVE parenting) but I am convinced some people are born wanting to watch the world burn.  And they should experience the natural consequences after a while.  You want to be trashy?  Go be trashy and see how far that gets you.  You want to hang out with delinquents?  Go on, but we aren't bailing you out when you get into trouble.  You want to take from people mentally, physically, psychologically, and emotionally?  People will eventually figure out who you are and normal people will weed themselves out of your life.  The trash will linger of course.

I'm not advocating for neglect or ignorance.  I am simply noticing that there are things far beyond our control, and we sometimes have to sadly back away, save ourselves and others who did no wrong and want no part of it, and let sh!t hit the fan for these lunatics.  The other thing with these types of people.... they always end up alone in the end.  They are so utterly insecure and jealous of what others have that they worked hard for, that they cannot stand to see it and have to insert themselves into it for likes but simultaneously degrade and hate the people attached to the wonderful things.  They love to be apart of the action but are sore losers and will turn on you when you look the other way.

I say... LET THEM!  People who reject help and do not care about their behavior impacting others should not continuously be a burden to others in any shape or form. 

Comments

MorningMia's picture

I agree that tigers generally don't change their stripes. I tend to think it's a mix of genetics/nature and nurture. I think the earlier years in a child's life are when they are so impressionable, so if a genetic predisposition to goodness exists, that can be drawn out further just as a genetic predisposition to being an ass can be fed. 
I do know a number of people who had pretty horrific childhoods who ended up very kind adults, though. 
When I think of my skids, I see they are today who they were 20 years ago, and I wish I had fully and permanently disengaged much earlier. I kept giving them chances because I felt they had been brainwashed by their mother. SS actually got worse as he got older. But in the big picture, they never changed, they never matured (as we thought they might) in the way of becoming independent of their toxic and punishing mother. 
 

People who reject help and do not care about their behavior impacting others should not continuously be a burden to others in any shape or form.

Agreed! 

Hastings's picture

My DH is a living example of nature/nurture. He was adopted as a newborn, but we met his bio family about six years ago. (He was born when his parents were 18, but they went on to get married and have two more children.)

Some of his personality traits like strong emotions, anger management issues -- all his bio family. Even his fear of heights.

But there are traits that are definitely more in line with the people who raised him.

You bring up interesting points and sometimes I look at SS14 and wonder how much of his entitlement, self-centeredness, lack of empathy and disregard for rules is built in and how much is the result of BM and her family's spoiling.

JRI's picture

Like most naive parents, I thought I could mold my kids.  I've found that the little people they were born - that's who they are now as adults, just more so all the time.  So, the quiet, cuddly baby boy is now a calm, affectionate man.  Nurture plays a role, of course, but the temperament they were born with - thats who they are.

Harry's picture

Have a major impact on one's life. That a thing that can not be changed, maybe treated ?  2

Dogmom1321's picture

I agree! 99.9% is how kids are hardwired. I feel parents blame other factors instead of accepting their children as they are (lazy, rude, entitled, no empathy, etc.). I am a teacher and have seen MANY kids with trauma. Some have become very resilisent and successful! The ones who are not play the blame game. Terrible Disney Dads and HCBM only contribute to their failed spawn. 

ESMOD's picture

It all matters.. Genetics, childhood experience.  But, even when you have seemingly similar experience and genetics, kids can and do turn out differently.  My YSD and OSD are different in a lot of ways.  I do think that they both have tendencies from both their parents, and the older one probably felt more weight of her parent's split since she was older when it happened.  The younger one basically grew up in the situation since it happened when she was very young.  

Younger also had the benefit of "me" in the home and was more open to my influence.. and for that reason, I feel has turned out a bit "better" than her older sister.. with less of a "why me.. blame the world" attitude.. more of a I can be an independent woman who can stand on my own two feet..but can also be in a healthy relationship.

There also can be mental health issues that are both genetic and also rooted in the family dynamics at home.. and some of that is rooted in very young minds...