The whispering SD
I have been with DH for 4 years and married for 2. I have tried to like my 10 yo SD, but I am to the point of giving up. She does not talk to anyone when she comes to our house accept DH. If you say hi she barely responds. If I ask her a question she usually doesn't answer. If she needs something she whispers to DH. If we go out to dinner she has to sit next to DH and whispers to him the entire time. It makes me so angry! DH says she is shy. I say she is rude! I try to engage in conversation by asking her how her day was at the dinner table. DH said I should only be asking her questions one on one because I am making her uncomfortable. Umm she has lived with us 50% for the last 3 years as well as my 2 bio sons. She won't speak to my extended family. My mom has given her gifts for birthdays and Christmas and never once has said thank you. In fact DH gets upset that she isn't included in things that my family does, but why would they include someone that doesn't talk to them?
SD is the most spoiled child by BM. She gets whatever she wants clothes shoes you name it. My son (who is 3 years older) got his first cell phone. BM went out and got SD a brand new iPhone 12! DH and I agreed it was not a good idea to get SD a phone because she has already been caught 2x for watching pornography at BM's house on her bio sisters iPad, but BM went ahead and got it anyway. DH and I are near getting a divorce because of her. He wants the Brady Bunch and I don't want anything to do with her. My boys don't like her either because she will tattle to DH on them for not being nice to her and then they get in trouble. So now they just avoid her. I want to save my marriage. I do love my DH, but how I will survive the next 8 years in my house with my whispering SD? I don't know.
The whispering is rude as
The whispering is rude as hell and your husband shouldn't allow it. Enough of the excuses!
She is only 10...the teen years will be even worse.
If your husband doesn't do anything to correct this and he keeps making excuses for her... your marriage likely will not last.
If SD is whispering to Dad
If SD is whispering to Dad and not speaking to you, I'd tell him that she appears to have "selective mutism" and he needs to enroll her in counseling to fix this.
Hold on tight, just a little bit longer
Your story sounds so very similar to mine. All I want to say is, if you really love your husband and want your marriage to work, take it one day at a time. Never show her that she upsets you, that will only make her enjoy it more. I once read an article in a magazine which says: she will finish school and leave the house one day, then you still have your marriage. My SD was also around 10 years old at that stage. I hold on to that article and it motivated me to to keep going. What I did not know at that stage, was the worst was yet to come. At age 14-17 was the worst. SD posted on social media about me. It was the most terrible years of my life. I thought of taking my own life many times, because I had stress at word and stress at home. DH got angry with me every time I wanted to discuss SD. When SD was 17, we went for councelling. The psychologist said its clear that BM was the mastermind behind SD's negative attitute. SD left school and home 7 years ago. Although I know we'll never be very close, we hug each other when we see each other and we can even have a civil conversation. Don't give up on your marriage. Don't give up on your DH. Get a nice hobby or something you can put your energy into and shift your focus away from the negative environment or situation. In a few years time, it will be all behind you. xx
Well, it's up to you if you
Well, it's up to you if you want to stay with him. But most stepkids don't leave at 18, especially those who are enmeshed with their enabling father.
I personally would be civil and pleasant to her, but nothing more. And I sure as hell would not go out to dinner (or even eat dinner at home) with her. Or be in any other situation where DH allows her to be rude to me.
I'm pretty sure I'd also lose all love and respect for DH. Some people seem able to separate their partner's lousy parenting and enmeshment with his kids from their feelings for him, but I don't think I could do that. I'd be very resentful and unhappy if I was blamed for his inability to be an effective parent to his kid.
Zero tolerance.
"EXCUSE ME! Speak up. No one can hear you. Whispering is rude so either speak up where everyone can hear or keep your mouth shut." Lather...... rinse....... repeat.
^^This^^
^^This^^
YES
Who cares what DH will say, what Rags said is the correct way. We are so consumed with not rocking the boat with DH so we end up enabling DH to enable the shit skids.
DH is the problem, but we keep the problem going in fear DH will be pissed. If I could go back in time my ex SD would get a mouthful. I feared DH being upset with me because I stood up to the lil B, I was an idiot. Do not let a 10 yr old ruin your life.
I was a shy child too. But I
I was a shy child too. But I sure as hell knew I had to say please and thank you and hello and goodbye and answer questions address to me.
What will this child do when she's in a new situation -- new school, college, roommates, job, boss, etc.? WIll Daddy be there to speak for her?
Your DH is crippling his own child by not teaching her to handle normal social interactions. She doesn't have to be a chatterbox, but she does have to engage in normal activities. What in the world does she think will happen when she says outloud, instead of whispering to her father, "please pass the potatoes?"
I don't know... This year
I don't know... This year with virtual she hasn't had to interact much with others, but last year she didn't talk to her teacher for almost 4 months! At conferences the teacher told BM and DH that he wasn't able to assess her because she refused to talk to him. The weird thing is she is constantly talking with friends, but again it's whispering.
I hear you....
Hi, I appreciate your post. I came into the picture when my SD was 11 years old. In the beginning, I tried very hard to befriend her and get her to like me. It was ok for awhile until her dad and I married and she was 13. Then all hell broke lose.
I noticed she only acted as if she liked me when I said yes and gave her things. When I said no, I was "stepwitch" and "not family." She would call her father a traitor. I was ignored purposefully. She stole clothing from my closet. She would purposefully do things to get under my skin, like saying, well dad's had many girlfriends or "this is my house." She would have angry outbursts, slam doors, throw things and scream at my husband.
It's safe to say, kids that act like this have issues. They are angry and obviously not getting their needs met. Their PARENTS should be working on this via counseling, spending 1/1 time, etc.)
If you feel that you are really trying, but it's making you unwell perhaps create bounderies and consider pulling back. It doesn't need to be drastic or dramatic, just matter of fact and polite. Here is what worked for me:
1. When she starts the bad behavior, disengage and "pleasantly" leave the room to find other things to do. I keep a list of things I'd love to work on or get done like my scrapbooks or catching up on work. When DH asks what I am doing, I just tell him that I didn't like the behavior and rather than getting upset about it, I decided to take a break.
2. Do NOT show your emotions, irritations, disgust, etc. That will just fuel the fire and give more ammo. It's hard, but I noticed if you ignore the behavior, it tends to dissapate. I also don't feel like I stooped to the child's level. When she makes the "dad has had many girlfriend comments" to me or others, I lnow augh and say, "yeah, I did too...several!"
3. Not your kid, not your problem. You are not responsible for her development. If she doesn't have any friends, cannot adapt to situations, grow into a considerate person, that is for your DH to worry about. Be a sounding board, but don't get involved. Trust me, it won't help, work or do good for your marriage.
4. If she doesn't want to be nice or respectful to me, then she doesn't get anything from me. I don't make special meals, drive, purchase things, give or lend her things anymore. I no longer take the lead in birthday party planning, Xmas shopping, etc. I let my husband do that now.
I used to include her in my familiy outings and dinner with friends. That has stopped. If she takes something of mine, I retrieve it and tell dad. (He can do the punishing with my input.) I keep her at a distance, politely. When she is being nice and behaves, I will find something in common to do with her like watch a movie. I limit it to an activity that doesn't include her getting material things from me. I never lend advice unsolicited, and if Ishe asksl, I am very conservative with my feedback.
I don't do all of this to be mean. I do it to keep myself from being a martyr. It has helped my nerves and I am happier in my marriage too.
I really will have to work on
I really will have to work on not showing my emotions. I get so upset with her behaviors and I do not hide my emotions very well. I like the idea of leaving quietly and working on some hobbies. I have been hiding out in my bedroom, but I feel like this is my house and I shouldn't have to. I am going to try to disengage. I have been reading posts from the forum and I think that could work for me.
I think I have figured out that DH says he wants me to be involved in parenting SD10, but he actually doesn't mean it. He wants to treat her as he always has. He is enabling her and DH and BM will suffer the consequences in the future.
Thank you everyone for your feedback. It really helps to hear what has worked for others.